World Dueling Academy
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.



 
Hang-OutHomeLatest imagesSearchRegisterLog in

 

 Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.

Go down 
+2
AsianGuy1137
Minako
6 posters
AuthorMessage
Minako
WDA Member
WDA Member
Minako


Achievement Points : 6
Posts : 1379
Reputation : 1843
Waifu : Minako

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptyMon Jul 18, 2011 7:14 am

Okay so I noticed some confusion on mandatory effects like tengu the other day. Here is how they work. They cannot interrupt chains. If they happen at the time that other cards would miss then they in a sense miss too. However they HAVE to activate. So they activate once the current chain ends. So if you synch tengu to krebons to synchro summon brionac. Brionac is summoned. Tengu should miss but he'll force himself to activate later. Both you and your opponent are given a chance to respond to brionac's summon and if you do so, you'll start and complete a chain. Once that chain is over, tengu will activate and start a new chain. That's how it works.
Back to top Go down
AsianGuy1137
WDA Member
WDA Member
AsianGuy1137


Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 152
Reputation : 181
Waifu : AsianGuy1137

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptyTue Jul 19, 2011 3:06 am

I say we D Prison/Smash/Spin/any other kind of effect removal that sucker and then chain Oppression to its effect so we won't have to deal with it in the first place. Do kids still play with mandatory effects that activate simultaneously with another effect as the last things to resolve in a chain?
Back to top Go down
Minako
WDA Member
WDA Member
Minako


Achievement Points : 6
Posts : 1379
Reputation : 1843
Waifu : Minako

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptyTue Jul 19, 2011 3:11 am

I really don't get what you mean with that last bit. I brought this up partially for RO. Someone said this yesterday. "Tengu becomes chain link 1 and trish becomes chain link 2. Trish's effect will activate then tengu will." Which is wrong on many levels. He has the order of things right...but the wrong structure. This would prevent you from using RO on both monsters, which you can since they happen in separate chains. If they did chain then trish would cover for tengu.
Back to top Go down
Al-Bhed
Machina Mechanic
Machina Mechanic
Al-Bhed


Achievement Points : 50
Posts : 3724
Reputation : 4776
Waifu : fem-Al-Bhed

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptySun Aug 28, 2011 3:41 am

How did I miss this. Trish does chain to tengu. Mandatory effects will wait for the first chance to legally activate. They cannot initiate a chain in the summon negation window as they do not negate a summon and they cannot chain to something that can negate a summon as they are spell speed 1 so they wait for the summon response window to activate. When you summon Trishula, during the summon response window, where you can legally activate any spell speed 2 as well, Tengu will activate and Trishula will activate as well since that's where it triggers. As Tengu Triggered first he goes on chain Link 1 in the TCG (its mandatory too so it wouldnt matter in the OCG either) and then Trishula will occupy chain Link 2. Royal Oppression is another matter as it has to do with the summon negation window.

Well when you said respond to a summon you could be meaning summon negation where of course Tengu does not activate, but on the actual summon response window it does, and chains with whatever trigger effects are there, similar to the BRD-Dandylion combo, meaning the guy said nothing wrong about his chain (except from using the word "activate" instead of "resolve" ofc). You can use Royal Oppression in the summon negation window for trishula of course but on the summon response window yes, trishula will stop you from chaining royal oppression to tengu. Now as to why you chose to negate Tengu and not hte Trishula I don't know, debunk perhaps? That also means you wouldnt have priority to use Brionac's effect in this case as Tengu will force himself on chain link 1 and Brionac cannot chain to anything, so he is BTH-able before he can activate.
Back to top Go down
Minako
WDA Member
WDA Member
Minako


Achievement Points : 6
Posts : 1379
Reputation : 1843
Waifu : Minako

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptySun Aug 28, 2011 4:33 am

Honestly it took me a while to get why it will activate like this and I still don't get it. If a mandatory effect can force itself onto the chain summon response window then why do optional effects miss the timing in the summon response window. It'd make more sense to me that the mandatory effects "miss" and then start a new chain simply because they have to activate. Call me stupid but it just doesn't quite make sense to me.
Back to top Go down
Legendaryfrost
WDA Staff
WDA Staff
Legendaryfrost


Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 657
Reputation : 793
Waifu : LegendaryFrost

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptySun Aug 28, 2011 7:02 am

I understand it like this: Mandatory effects(don't have "can" and other words like that in the effect) WILL happen, meaning imo is the timing would somehow be missed under normal circumstances, the effect will activate after the previous one resolves. I got it from this example: Naturia cliff is tributed for Caius, now I beleive Caius will activate but cliff will NOT, just cuz the last thing to happen was the summon of caius and not cliff being sent to grave, hence the timing is missed, It all depends on the wording of the card, but for me, in order for it to not miss the timing, the conditions of the card effect must be the direct last thing to happen(unless the effect is mandatory in which case it will happen no matter what you do)
Back to top Go down
Al-Bhed
Machina Mechanic
Machina Mechanic
Al-Bhed


Achievement Points : 50
Posts : 3724
Reputation : 4776
Waifu : fem-Al-Bhed

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptySun Aug 28, 2011 7:13 am

Actually it's not only about mandatory. The only things that can miss the timing are "when..., you can" optional trigger effects. The "when" denotes time, it will activate "when" its trigger is met, not at another time, if "when" they were supposed to activate it was impossible to build a chain due to the game rules (while performing a summon, while resolving a chain etc.) then they miss the timing and miss their chance to activate, unless it is mandatory at which case it persists as we said here and will wait until the first chance to activate.

But there are also "if..., you can" optional trigger effects. These do not care if the timing is missed, they will activate "if" their trigger is met, and not "when" it is met, so they act like mandatory effects, they will wait and will activate at the time a mandatory effect would, whether they are optional or mandatory effects themselves. For example the scrap effects are optionals, but they have "if" so they dont care about timing, that's why chaining scrapstorm still works with them.

In the end missing the timing is quite a simple thing so long as you don't try to slap the term in everything you don't understand due to lack of knowledge. If a "when..., you can" optional trigger/trigger-like effect meets its trigger at a time you cannot build a chain immidiatelly and as a result when you can activate an effect it meeting its trigger was not the last thing to happen, then it has missed the timing and you cannot activate it. Missing the timing is that and only that, not when call of the haunted is chain link 2 when you have bottomless and not when you chose to let attack declaration go and decided to use your dimensional prison now. It is only the above.
Back to top Go down
rjuto
WDA Staff
 WDA Staff
rjuto


Achievement Points : 28
Posts : 1063
Reputation : 1397

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptySun Aug 28, 2011 7:35 am

^ What the guy said.
Back to top Go down
Dr. Chuckles
WDA Member
WDA Member
Dr. Chuckles


Achievement Points : 0
Posts : 458
Reputation : 560
Waifu : Dr. Chuckles

Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. EmptyWed Aug 31, 2011 3:48 pm

well that was very informative. thanks for the info minako and al
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.   Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen. Empty

Back to top Go down
 
Cause it's mandatory, so it...like just has to happen.
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» Cardfight Vanguard Singles Tournament Signups (lets make this happen!)

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
World Dueling Academy :: Yu-Gi-Oh! :: YGO Talk :: Articles-
Jump to: